← Story Library

Back From the Brink

Alan Mulally and the Red Slide at Ford

How a Boeing engineer saved Ford without a bailout by making it safe to tell the truth in the room.

In the fall of 2006, Ford Motor Company was losing money at a pace that frightened even people who had spent their whole careers in Detroit. The company would finish the year with a loss of $12.7 billion. Its debt had been rated junk, its market share was slipping, and its divisions around the world operated like separate kingdoms that rarely shared parts, platforms, or bad news. The man brought in to fix it had never run a car company. Alan Mulally had spent his career at Boeing, where he rose to lead the commercial airplane business.

Mulally became Ford's president and CEO on September 5, 2006, succeeding William Clay Ford Jr. Within months he made a decision that looked to many observers like an act of desperation. Ford borrowed roughly $23.5 billion and put up nearly all of its North American assets as collateral. That included factories and equipment, and it also included the trademarks for the Mustang, the F-150, and the famous blue oval itself. Mulally's stated reason was simple: the money would pay for a deep overhaul and serve as a cushion against a recession or some other shock nobody could yet see.

The shock came. When the financial crisis hit in 2008, credit froze and car sales collapsed. Ford lost billions more, and between 2006 and 2008 its losses added up to about $30 billion. General Motors and Chrysler went to Washington for rescue money and both went through bankruptcy in 2009. Ford did neither. The cushion it had borrowed before the storm carried it through. Mulally even testified before Congress in support of loans for his rivals, warning that their collapse could take down the parts suppliers all three companies shared.

Money alone does not explain the turnaround. Mulally's plan, called One Ford, asked a proud company to act as one team with one plan. Ford sold off its premium brands, including Aston Martin, Jaguar, Land Rover, and Volvo, so it could focus on the Ford name. It pulled regional operations that had worked like independent companies into one global organization. Underneath the slogans, the plan demanded something harder than restructuring. It asked executives to stop protecting their territory and start telling each other the truth.

His main tool for that was a meeting. Every Thursday morning at 7 a.m., Ford's senior leaders gathered for what Mulally called the Business Plan Review. Every leader reported on their part of the plan, and every item was color-coded. Green meant on track. Yellow meant a problem with a fix already underway. Red meant a problem without a solution yet. Attendance was required, and the purpose was plain: everyone in the room would see exactly where the company stood, every single week.

In the early weeks, the charts came in almost entirely green. The company was on its way to losing billions, yet nearly every slide said things were fine. Mulally finally asked the room, in so many words, how every line could be green when the company was losing billions, and whether anything at all was not going well. Nobody rushed to answer. In the Ford culture of that era, admitting a problem in front of the boss had long been a good way to damage a career. His executives had learned that lesson well, and a new CEO's question was not going to undo it overnight.

Then Mark Fields, who ran Ford's operations in the Americas, broke the pattern. A problem had turned up with the new Ford Edge crossover, built in Canada, and the launch would have to be held back. Fields put the item up in red. Accounts differ on the small details of what happened next, but they agree on the heart of it. Mulally clapped. He thanked Fields for the visibility and turned to the room to ask who could help. In the weeks that followed, yellow and red began to show up on other executives' charts, and the meetings turned into working sessions about how to fix things.

That moment changed what the meeting was for. It stopped being a stage for looking good and became a place to get help. Problems surfaced earlier, when they were smaller and cheaper to fix. Ford returned to profit in 2009 while its crosstown rivals were in bankruptcy, and it kept improving. In May 2012, after Moody's restored Ford's credit to investment grade, the company got its blue oval and the other pledged assets back. Mulally retired on July 1, 2014. His successor as CEO was Mark Fields, the man who had shown the first red slide.

Most managers will never borrow $23 billion or run a global automaker. But nearly every manager runs some version of the Thursday meeting. It might be a morning huddle, a weekly report, or a status update in a shared spreadsheet. And nearly every one of those meetings can catch the same disease Ford had. People report green because green is safe. A leader who meets bad news with irritation, sarcasm, or a public grilling will get exactly one thing from the team after that: more green.

What Mulally did is small enough to copy on Monday. Make the status of the work visible in a format everyone understands, with a clear meaning for each color or rating. When everything looks perfect but the results say otherwise, ask out loud why. And when someone finally brings you a real problem, watch your first reaction, because the whole team is watching it too. Thank the person. Then ask who can help, and make sure the help actually shows up.

Fear gets you green slides. Trust gets you the truth in time to act on it. The difference between the two is not a policy, a poster, or a value printed on the wall. It is what your face does the first time someone tells you something you did not want to hear.

The takeaway: Your team will tell you the truth exactly as often as it is safe to do so. When someone brings you a red slide, thank them first and ask who can help second.

The discipline

This story is a picture of Trust Gets Commitment, Chapter 6 of The Real Leader. Fear gets compliance. Trust gets commitment. This is what commitment looks like.

Read Chapter 6 in The Real Leader →

Share the lesson

Leading through something like this?

Describe your situation and get the diagnosis, the principle, and the exact words to say tomorrow.

Get counsel, free →
← All storiesNext story: Lou Gerstner Keeps IBM in One Piece →
Sources