← Story Library

Crews Under Pressure

Captain Sullenberger and the Miracle on the Hudson

Two pilots, three flight attendants, and 208 seconds: why everyone on Flight 1549 survived, and why it was no miracle.

At 3:27 in the afternoon on January 15, 2009, US Airways Flight 1549 was climbing out of LaGuardia Airport bound for Charlotte. The Airbus A320 was at about 2,800 feet, roughly four and a half miles from the runway, when the windshield filled with large birds. They were Canada geese. Passengers heard loud bangs and saw flames from the engines. Within seconds, both engines had lost nearly all their thrust. The airplane was over the most densely populated city in America, too low to glide far, carrying 150 passengers and 5 crew members.

In the left seat was Captain Chesley Sullenberger, 57, a former Air Force fighter pilot with nearly 20,000 hours of flying time, a glider pilot, and a longtime student of aviation safety. In the right seat was First Officer Jeffrey Skiles, 49, with more than 15,000 hours of his own. Skiles had been flying the leg. Sullenberger took the controls, and Skiles handed them over. In the cabin were three flight attendants, Sheila Dail, Donna Dent, and Doreen Welsh. Nobody aboard had time to prepare. Everything that happened next came from preparation that had already been done.

The two pilots divided the work instantly. Sullenberger flew the airplane and handled the radio and the decisions. Skiles went to the emergency checklist for a dual-engine failure and began working through it, trying to restart the engines. That checklist had been written assuming a failure at high altitude, with time to work through several pages. At low altitude there was no such time, and Skiles had to move through it fast and decide what mattered most. Early in the sequence, Sullenberger started the auxiliary power unit, a small engine in the tail. The NTSB later found that decision kept a primary source of electrical power available and preserved the airplane's flight-control protections all the way down.

Air traffic control offered a return to LaGuardia and then Teterboro Airport in New Jersey. Sullenberger weighed the options against the airplane's altitude and speed and concluded he could not make a runway. If he tried and fell short, the airplane would come down in neighborhoods. On the cockpit recording he told the controller, "We're gonna be in the Hudson." Then he made one announcement to the cabin: brace for impact. In the back, the flight attendants began shouting their brace commands to the passengers.

About 208 seconds after the bird strike, the airplane touched down on the Hudson River. The water was about 41 degrees and the air about 19. The fuselage stayed intact and floated. The flight attendants opened their exits and got people moving, even though every one of them ran into trouble at their doors. Doreen Welsh, in the back, was badly cut on her leg by a beam that broke through the floor. At the front, one slide-raft failed to inflate automatically and had to be inflated by hand. Passengers climbed onto the wings and into the rafts. Commuter ferries and rescue boats reached the airplane within minutes.

All 155 people survived. Some were seriously injured, and many were cold and shaken, but every person who boarded that airplane went home. Sullenberger walked the cabin twice before leaving to make sure no one was left behind.

The NTSB investigation, finished in 2010, is worth reading for what it credits. The board found that the professionalism of the flight crew and their excellent crew resource management contributed to their ability to keep control and fly a survivable approach. It found that the decision to ditch on the Hudson rather than attempt an airport gave everyone the highest probability of surviving. It found that the flight attendants started the evacuation promptly and managed an effective, timely evacuation despite trouble at every exit. And it found gaps too: a checklist not designed for a low-altitude dual-engine failure, and passengers who largely ignored the safety briefing and left most life vests under their seats.

Notice what the board did not say. It did not credit one man's instinct. It credited a crew. Crew resource management is the discipline airlines adopted after a string of accidents in which a captain's authority silenced a first officer who saw the danger. It teaches pilots to divide work clearly, speak up, cross-check, and treat the cockpit and the cabin as one team. On Flight 1549, that training let two pilots who each had a different job do both jobs at once, and let three flight attendants run an evacuation nobody had rehearsed on that river.

Sullenberger has said much the same thing himself in the years since. The landing lasted three and a half minutes, but the crew had been preparing for it for decades. Every simulator session, every checklist drill, every briefing that seemed routine was a deposit into an account they did not know they would need. On that afternoon they made the withdrawal.

For a manager, the first lesson is that your team will perform in a crisis exactly as well as you trained them before it. You will not rise to the occasion. You will fall back on what you practiced. If your people have never rehearsed who does what when the main system fails, they will improvise, and improvising under pressure is how mistakes multiply. Run the drill. Make it realistic. Talk through the scenario no one wants to think about.

The second lesson is about dividing the work. In the cockpit, one person flew the airplane while the other worked the problem. Neither tried to do both. In your crisis, decide fast who is keeping the business running and who is solving the problem. Then let each do their job without interruption.

The third lesson is about credit. The story the world told was about one captain. The story the investigators told was about five crew members, a well-built airplane, and boat crews who came running. When things go right on your team, tell the whole story. Name the people in the back of the airplane. The next time the engines go quiet, you will need every one of them ready.

The takeaway: Your team will not rise to the emergency; it will fall back on its training. Build the drills, divide the roles, and give credit to the whole crew, because that is who will save you.

The discipline

This story is a picture of Fly the Airplane, Chapter 4 of The Real Leader. Fear gets compliance. Trust gets commitment. This is what commitment looks like.

Read Chapter 4 in The Real Leader →

Share the lesson

Leading through something like this?

Describe your situation and get the diagnosis, the principle, and the exact words to say tomorrow.

Get counsel, free →
← All storiesNext story: Ernest Shackleton and the Endurance →
Sources